Everyone runs a Black Friday sale. Including me, for clients, every year.
Discounting isn't the problem. Discounting by default is. When every holiday email is the same 20% off with a bigger number each day, you teach your list one thing: wait. Holiday email marketing works better when every offer is on purpose.
If you want your holiday promo planned, written, and loaded for you, that's what the House Call's launch and sale support is for. Learn more here.
Are holiday discounts bad for your brand?
No. Holiday discounts work, and your customers expect one. The risk is running them without a plan, so your list learns that the price is always about to drop.
Klaviyo's own Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2025 data makes the case for discounting on purpose. Across its brands, consumer spending rose 11% while average discounts fell 10%. The brands offering the smallest discounts saw the highest growth, up 14% year over year. (1)
Average discount depth went from 29.6% in 2024 to 26.2% in 2025 (2). Shoppers still bought. They didn't need the deepest number on the internet to do it.
Smaller discounts, more spending. The number isn't necessarily what moves people. The offer is.
How do I run a Black Friday sale without training my list to wait?
Change the offer mechanic, not only the number. If each phase of your sale works differently, there's no "wait for the bigger discount" pattern for your list to learn.
The structure I use most for women's health brands runs in five phases. This is the same exact one I used last year that created a record-breaking 2025 Black Friday for Dr. Anna Cabeca.
VIP early access (about a week). Past customers and engaged subscribers only. Tiered bundle pricing instead of a flat discount: buy more, save more. It raises order value and rewards your best people first.
Public launch (a few days). Everyone else. One product spotlight per email, with real customer stories.
Thanksgiving thank-you. No offer in the body. A real thank-you, with a soft P.S. at most. It resets attention before the loudest two days of the year.
Black Friday (48 hours). The simplest offer of the whole sale: one flat discount, one real deadline. By now your list knows the products. Don't make them think.
Cyber Monday (72 hours). One product, one mechanic, like buy one get one, with a real quantity limit. It reads as a new event, not a sale that won't end.
And here’s the most important part: leave out anyone who’s already bought in this sale, or in the days right before it started. Nothing makes people madder than learning they could’ve saved if they’d only waited.
Holiday email ideas that don't depend on a deeper discount
You don't need a bigger percentage to give people a reason to buy now. Some of the best holiday offers for wellness brands aren't price cuts at all.
Bundles
"Stock up" bundles work well for supplements and anything people reorder. Tie the savings to quantity, and the discount pays for itself in order value.
Gift with purchase
Pick the free gift by asking what you want them buying in January. A gift that's your next launch puts the product in thousands of hands before you ever announce it.
Subscriber-only offers
If you sell subscriptions, give subscribers a different offer than one-time buyers, like a discount on an added product instead of their existing order. One-time sales shouldn't eat your recurring revenue.
Early access
Early access costs you nothing and makes your list feel like insiders. For a lot of brands, it's the offer.
What should a holiday email sequence include?
A holiday email sequence needs more than offer emails. Each email has one job, and the jobs change as the sale goes on.
The announcement. What's happening, when, and who gets in first.
The education emails. What each product does and who it's for. This is where your expertise sells.
The proof emails. Real customer stories, used with permission.
The no-pitch email. A short, sincere note from the founder with no hard sell. Hit reply and tell me what you need. It's the email that keeps the whole sale from feeling like a siege.
The deadline emails. A real deadline, stated plainly, a few times.
The last-chance email. Say it's the last one, and mean it.
Most brands skip number 4. Don't. What’s crazy is these are some of the highest-grossing sends.
Keep the claims clean during the sale
Holiday emails get written fast, and fast is when claims slip. "Kick your sugar cravings before the holidays" or "beat holiday bloat" lands differently in a supplement email than in a recipe post.
Your sale emails follow the same rules as every other email. Keep product claims in structure/function territory, and only use deadlines and quantity limits that are true. I broke down the claims part in What You Can Actually Say: Structure/Function Claims in Your Emails.
It's mid-November. Is it too late to plan holiday emails?
It's late, but not too late. Shorten the plan instead of skipping it.
With a week or two, cut it to three moves: an early access email to your best customers, one clear Black Friday offer with a real deadline, and one Cyber Monday offer that works differently.
Write the no-pitch email too. It takes ten minutes.
FAQ
How many emails should I send for Black Friday?
More than you'd send in a normal week. Holiday inboxes are crowded, and most of your list won't see every email. Spread them across phases with a different job for each, so it doesn't read like the same email five times.
When should I start sending holiday emails?
Start early access about a week before Black Friday. Announce it to your best customers before the public sale.
Should wellness brands discount at all?
If it fits your brand and your margins, yes. Plan it so each phase has a reason to exist, and the discount isn't the only reason to buy.
What's the difference between a holiday sale and a flash sale?
A holiday sale runs on the calendar everyone shares. A flash sale runs on your own calendar, often with less warning. The same rules apply to both: a real deadline, a clear offer, and a reason to buy now.
Launch and sale support
The House Call includes a weekly email in your voice, every month. Launch and sale support adds the extra emails and SMS for promos like this one, planned and written for you, with every claim reviewed. Learn more about the House Call.
References
Klaviyo. Klaviyo Breaks Records with First AI-Powered BFCM (press release, Business Wire). December 2, 2025. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20251202774732/en/klaviyo-breaks-records-with-first-ai-powered-bfcm
Klaviyo. Why Big Results Don't Need Big Discounts. December 2, 2025. https://www.klaviyo.com/blog/why-big-results-dont-need-big-discounts

